Eli was going away, leaving for a year. That was the plan. With so much love for Johnny and Casey, he didn't want either of them to be alone. It was obvious they'd fallen in love with one another while Eli was gone before, even if they'd both claimed to be in love with him. So, what was Eli to do? He gave them his blessing.
"Orange you going to kiss?"
But then Eli's plans changed, and he came home, just in time for Valentine's Day, a day that started it all with him and Johnny, a day with significance to him and Casey, and Johnny and Casey, too. Three men with a mishmash of sexual and romantic feelings, though none of them had an easy answer, the adorable primates they cared for and cherished offered an obvious one.
